Why Defending Ties With Turkey Is the Most Honest Move in Foreign Policy

Why Defending Ties With Turkey Is the Most Honest Move in Foreign Policy

Outrage is cheap. Diplomacy is not.

Every time a Western leader defends diplomatic or commercial ties with a government cracking down on LGBTQ groups, the predictable script plays out. Critics call it hypocrisy. Activists demand severance. Op-eds mourn the death of values-based foreign policy.

And then the cameras move on.

When Mark Carney defends maintaining ties with Turkey despite Ankara’s domestic crackdown on LGBTQ organizations and activists, the lazy consensus frames it as a moral failure. Either you stand for human rights, the argument goes, or you are an enabler. Pick a side. Look virtuous. Feel superior.

That framing is intellectually lazy. Worse, it gets the mechanics of international leverage completely backward.

Cutting off diplomatic and economic channels with a major regional power does not magically protect queer people in Istanbul or Ankara. Usually, it does the opposite. It removes whatever thin thread of external visibility, legal scrutiny, or institutional pressure still exists, while handing domestic hardliners a gift: proof that foreign critics are hostile outsiders rather than actors with skin in the game.

If you actually care about protecting vulnerable communities abroad, moral grandstanding feels great on a podium and achieves very little on the ground.

The Lazy Consensus Around Diplomatic Severance

The standard critique of engagement with authoritarian or backsliding states relies on a comforting binary. Engagement equals approval. Isolation equals resistance.

That binary is convenient because it lets commentators avoid hard trade-offs. You don’t have to weigh trade flows, migration pressures, regional security, or consular access when you reduce foreign policy to a purity test. You just point at a government’s abuses—and in Turkey’s case, restrictions on pride marches, bans on events, pressure on civil society groups, and rhetorical hostility toward LGBTQ identities are well-documented realities—and declare that any sustained relationship is a betrayal.

Here is the flaw in that logic. States are not individuals shaking hands at a dinner party. Maintaining an embassy, keeping trade lines open, or staying at the negotiating table is not a certificate of good behavior. It is a channel.

Once you sever a channel, you lose the ability to use it. You lose quiet diplomatic pushback behind closed doors. You lose business networks that sometimes push for predictable legal norms and workplace protections. You lose leverage over supply chains and regional security files where Ankara holds real cards.

I have watched policy teams and corporate boards burn through millions of dollars chasing performative exits from difficult markets, only to discover six months later that they had zero influence left over the people they claimed to want to help. Walking away is easy. Staying engaged without losing your spine—or your clarity—is the hard part.

What People Are Actually Asking When They Search This

When a story breaks about a leader defending ties with Turkey amid an LGBTQ crackdown, people type predictable questions into search bars. Most of those questions start from a shaky premise.

"Should leaders cut ties with countries that crack down on LGBTQ rights?"

Wrong question. The better question is: What specific mechanism actually improves safety and legal standing for LGBTQ people in that country, and does cutting ties strengthen or weaken it?

If severing diplomatic or trade ties forced governments to reverse civil society crackdowns, history would look very different. Often, isolation entrenches regimes, narrows space for domestic reformers, and pushes local activists further into the shadows without foreign observers watching. Engagement can also be abused or watered down—no serious observer denies that—but treating isolation as an automatic win confuses noise with impact.

"Is defending ties with Turkey hypocritical?"

By the standards of pure moralism, sure. By the standards of statecraft, no.

Every government balances competing imperatives: economic resilience, alliance management, regional stability, and human rights. Calling out hypocrisy is the easiest sport in political commentary because almost every state falls short of its highest rhetoric somewhere. The real test isn’t whether a leader sounds pure. It’s whether their strategy produces real-world protection or just domestic applause.

"Can trade and diplomacy coexist with human rights advocacy?"

They coexist every single day—messily, unevenly, and without neat resolution.

In international relations, engagement refers to maintaining formal diplomatic, economic, or security channels with another state, whereas endorsement implies political or moral approval of its domestic policies. Conflating the two is one of the most common mistakes in public debate. A diplomat sitting across from a Turkish official is not cosigning every decree issued by the interior ministry; they are operating inside a system of competing interests and constraints.

Heavyweights in international politics—from seasoned diplomats like Henry Kissinger in his realist critiques to political scientists like Robert Keohane and Joseph Nye analyzing complex interdependence—have spent decades showing that states operate in tangled networks of interest and vulnerability. Pretending those networks disappear when you get angry doesn’t change reality. It just blinds you to it.

A Thought Experiment in Leverage

Imagine a scenario where a Western government abruptly suspends high-level diplomatic contact and freezes major commercial ties with Ankara over its LGBTQ crackdown.

On day one, headlines praise the decisive stand. Activists abroad cheer the moral clarity.

Now trace what happens over the next eighteen months. Ankara frames the move as foreign interference targeting Turkish sovereignty and traditional values. Hardline voices gain rhetorical fuel. Local LGBTQ groups facing state pressure lose international diplomatic backing and routine contact with foreign missions that might otherwise monitor trials, support civil society exchange, or raise specific cases quietly. Meanwhile, competitors from regions with zero interest in human rights step into the commercial and strategic vacuum left behind.

Who won that exchange? Not queer citizens in Turkey. The people who won were politicians who wanted a convenient external enemy and pundits who wanted a clean narrative.

That thought experiment doesn’t prove that engagement always works. It proves something simpler and harder: leverage—the capacity to shape another actor’s incentives—rarely comes from slamming the door shut and walking into the hallway.

Where This Contrarian Take Can Go Wrong

Let’s be honest about the downside, because pretending there is no catch is how bad policy gets sold.

The biggest risk of defending ties in the name of pragmatism is quiet capitulation. When leaders talk endlessly about "constructive engagement" and "complex realities," it is dangerously easy for human rights to slide to the bottom of the agenda and stay there. Pragmatism without accountability turns into convenience.

There is also a reputational cost. If a government defends ties with Ankara while saying very little—or saying nothing publicly—when queer activists are detained or events are banned, critics have every right to call that cowardice masked as realism. Keeping the door open only makes sense if you actually walk through it to press hard issues, protect human rights defenders, and refuse to treat civil liberties as a taboo topic.

And in business, there is the risk of moral laundering. Companies that keep operating in restrictive environments sometimes slap a generic inclusion statement on a slide deck while staying silent on local hostility. That isn’t smart strategy; it’s window dressing.

What Actually Works Instead of Performative Outrage

If you want a policy—or a corporate posture—that is tougher than posture politics and smarter than naive optimism, stop looking for slogans and start looking at pressure points.

  1. Separate diplomatic channels from moral silence. Keep embassy doors open, keep bilateral channels functioning, and pair them with unmistakable public and private advocacy for freedom of association, assembly, and expression. Silence isn’t strategy; it’s surrender.
  2. Back local civil society without turning them into props. Support legal aid, documentation, and safe spaces quietly and reliably where lawful and safe to do so, rather than treating marginalized groups as talking points during a news cycle.
  3. Use economic leverage where it actually bites. Multinational firms with operations or supply chains in Turkey have real influence on internal workplace policies, anti-discrimination standards, and employee safety. Enforce high standards inside your own footprint instead of issuing press releases from thousands of miles away.
  4. Judge leaders by outcomes, not speeches. Don’t measure foreign policy by how tough a statement sounds. Measure whether consular access, human rights monitoring, and practical protections improve or deteriorate.

The Uncomfortable Truth About Statecraft

Foreign policy is not a purity contest. It is a contest of incentives, constraints, and consequences.

Critics love a clean villain and a simple exit because clean stories require less work than messy realities. Defending ties with Turkey amid an LGBTQ crackdown draws fire precisely because it refuses to hand out easy moral trophies.

Real influence requires staying in the arena, taking the heat, and using every ounce of leverage you actually possess—not throwing away your tools just to look good on camera.

MR

Mia Rivera

Mia Rivera is passionate about using journalism as a tool for positive change, focusing on stories that matter to communities and society.