Why Monetarism Still Matters in 2026

Why Monetarism Still Matters in 2026

Central bankers spent three decades pretending the money supply didn't matter. Then 2021 happened, M2 exploded by over 26% in a single year, and inflation hit a forty-year high.

If you want to know whether monetarism should stage a comeback, the short answer is yes—but not in the rigid, mechanical way Milton Friedman originally pitched it. We can't go back to the 1970s playbook of blindly targeting a fixed 3% money growth rule. Financial plumbing has changed too much for that. Yet ignoring money supply aggregates completely, which became the standard operating procedure at the Federal Reserve and the European Central Bank from the 1990s until the early 2020s, proved to be a massive policy blunder.

Watching central bank press conferences over the last few years has been honestly baffling. Officials spent months debating supply chains, shipping containers, and labor shortages while barely uttering the words "money supply." They looked at every micro-level friction in the economy while ignoring the giant elephant sitting in the room—trillions of newly created dollars sloshing through bank accounts.

What Monetarism Actually Says

Strip away the academic jargon and monetarism boils down to a simple equation. Milton Friedman famously argued that inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon. He backed this up using the equation of exchange, $MV = PQ$.

Here is how that works in plain English. $M$ is the money supply. $V$ is the velocity of money, or how fast a dollar changes hands in a year. $P$ is the price level, and $Q$ is the real output of goods and services.

If the economy produces roughly the same amount of stuff ($Q$), and people spend their money at roughly the same pace ($V$), pumping a massive amount of new cash ($M$) into the system forces prices ($P$) to go up. It's basic math. You have more dollars chasing the exact same number of cars, houses, and cartons of eggs.

For decades, this was gospel. In 1979, Federal Reserve Chair Paul Volcker famously used monetarist principles to break the back of double-digit inflation. He stopped targeting interest rates directly and instead clamped down on the growth of bank reserves. Interest rates skyrocketed to 20%, the economy went through a brutal recession, and inflation finally died.

Why Economists Abandoned It

So why did everyone dump monetarism in the trash bin by the 1990s? Because $V$—velocity—stopped behaving itself.

Friedman's entire framework relied on the idea that the velocity of money was relatively stable and predictable. If you knew how fast money moved, you could control inflation simply by adjusting the spigot on the money supply.

Then came financial deregulation, credit cards, money market funds, and algorithmic trading. What even counted as "money" became blurry. Was it physical cash and checking accounts (M1)? Did you include savings accounts and retail money market funds (M2)? What about institutional funds and repurchase agreements (M3)?

During the 1980s and 1990s, the Fed tried targeting M1, missed its targets constantly, and watched velocity swing wildly. By 1993, Fed Chair Alan Greenspan officially told Congress that the central bank was downgrading monetary aggregates as a guide for policy. In 2000, the Fed stopped setting target ranges for money supply growth altogether.

Instead, central banks adopted New Keynesian frameworks. They focused almost entirely on setting short-term interest rates—like the federal funds rate—using variations of the Taylor Rule. In their models, money became purely endogenous. Banks created loans based on credit demand, and the central bank simply supplied whatever reserves were needed to keep interest rates at the target level. Money supply wasn't a driver anymore; it was just an accounting byproduct.

For twenty-five years, this looked like genius. Then came the 2008 financial crisis.

When the Fed launched Quantitative Easing (QE) in 2008, old-school monetarists screamed that hyperinflation was right around the corner. They looked at the explosion in the monetary base—bank reserves held at the Fed—and predicted Weimar-style price spikes.

It didn't happen. Inflation stayed stubbornly below 2% for a decade.

Why were the monetarists wrong in 2009? Because they looked at the wrong measure of money. During QE1, QE2, and QE3, the Fed bought bonds from banks and credited their reserve accounts. That expanded the monetary base (M0), not the broad money supply (M2) that regular people actually spend. Banks sat on those excess reserves instead of lending them out, and velocity collapsed. New Keynesian economists took a victory lap, declaring monetarism dead and buried forever.

The 2020 Vindication

Victory laps rarely age well in economics.

When COVID-19 hit in March 2020, policymakers didn't just do QE. They combined massive central bank asset purchases with direct fiscal transfers—stimulus checks, enhanced unemployment benefits, and Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) loans deposited straight into commercial checking accounts.

This time, the money didn't stay trapped in bank reserves at the Fed. Broad money (M2) surged by an unprecedented 26.9% between February 2020 and February 2021, according to Federal Reserve Economic Data (FRED).

A handful of economists—including Steve Hanke at Johns Hopkins University, John Greenwood, and Tim Congdon—sounded the alarm immediately. Using classic monetarist math, they predicted in early 2021 that US inflation would hit 6% to 9% within eighteen months.

Mainstream economists laughed them off. Fed Chair Jerome Powell repeatedly insisted in 2021 that inflation was "transitory" and driven by supply bottlenecks in semiconductors and used cars. The models used by the Fed didn't even have a variable for M2 growth. Because interest rates were near zero and inflation expectations looked anchored, their equations told them everything was fine.

By June 2022, the Consumer Price Index (CPI) hit 9.1%.

The monetarists didn't get lucky. They looked at the right variable. Supply chain issues explain why the price of lumber or microchips spikes temporarily relative to other goods. They cannot explain why the price of everything—rent, haircuts, groceries, insurance, restaurant meals—rises simultaneously by 8% or 9%. You only get a generalized rise in the price level when the purchasing power of the currency itself drops, and that happens when the supply of money outpaces the supply of goods.

What Happens When Money Shrinks

If you still doubt the power of the money supply, look at what happened on the way down.

In 2022, the Fed finally woke up, hiked interest rates aggressively, and began Quantitative Tightening (QT)—shrinking its balance sheet. By December 2022, year-over-year M2 growth turned negative for the first time since the Great Depression. It stayed in contraction territory throughout 2023.

Monetarists like Congdon and Hanke argued that this monetary contraction guaranteed a sharp drop in inflation without needing a catastrophic spike in unemployment. Meanwhile, many Wall Street economists using traditional Phillips Curve models warned that inflation was "sticky" and could only be cured by throwing millions of people out of work.

Inflation fell from 9.1% to under 3% by mid-2024, while the unemployment rate barely budged above 4%. The contraction in broad money did the heavy lifting, just as the quantity theory of money predicted it would.

Where Monetarism Still Falls Short

Admitting that monetarism got the big picture right doesn't mean we should blindly worship Milton Friedman. Hardcore monetarism has serious flaws that make a pure comeback impossible.

First, the definition of money is still a moving target. Stablecoins, money market mutual funds, Treasury bills held in retail brokerage accounts, and high-yield digital wallets blur the line between cash and investments. In 2023 and 2024, billions of dollars flowed out of traditional bank deposits (which are counted in M2) and into Treasury-only money market funds or direct T-bills (some of which sit outside standard M2 definitions) because yields were higher. If you rely mechanically on a single M2 number without understanding where the cash is hiding, you will misread the economy.

Second, Friedman's k-percent rule doesn't work in the real world. Friedman wanted central banks to abolish discretionary policy entirely and simply grow the money supply by a fixed rate—say, 3% to 4%—every single year, come hell or high water. We tried soft versions of this in the 1980s, and it failed. Financial crises require central banks to act as lenders of last resort. During a panic like March 2020 or the 2023 Silicon Valley Bank collapse, everyone suddenly wants to hoard cash. Velocity crashes. If the central bank refuses to inject liquidity because of a rigid rule, the banking system freezes and triggers a depression.

Third, central banks don't directly control broad money. They control the monetary base (cash and bank reserves). Commercial banks create the vast majority of broad money when they issue loans. If businesses and households are terrified of debt—like in Japan during the 1990s or the US in 2009—the central bank can print reserves all day long, and M2 still won't grow fast enough to generate inflation. Fiscal policy (government deficit spending funded by bank credit) plays a massive role in turning central bank reserves into spendable M2.

Building a Better Hybrid Framework

We don't need to choose between ignoring money completely and chaining the Fed to a 1970s computer algorithm. The smart move is a hybrid framework—what some economists call pragmatic monetarism or the "two-pillar" approach.

Interestingly, the European Central Bank actually started out with a two-pillar strategy in 1999. The first pillar analyzed short-term economic shocks, while the second pillar monitored monetary aggregates (specifically M3) as a cross-check on medium-term inflation risks. Over time, the ECB quietly let the monetary pillar gather dust.

Reviving that cross-check fixes the biggest blind spot in modern central banking. Here is how central banks—and investors—should actually use monetarism today.

Treat M2 as a smoke alarm, not a steering wheel. You don't need to fine-tune interest rates every month based on minor wiggles in weekly money supply data. Normal fluctuations of 4% to 7% annual M2 growth are just noise. You use it to catch extremes. When broad money grows above 10% for more than two quarters, or contracts below 0%, the alarm should go off. That signals a major regime shift in inflation or deflation risk twelve to eighteen months down the road.

Track fiscal and monetary coordination. Stop pretending central banks operate in a vacuum. When the government runs massive deficits and the central bank buys the resulting bonds (monetizing the debt), broad money explodes. Watching the interplay between Treasury issuance and central bank balance sheets tells you whether newly created liquidity is staying trapped on Wall Street or entering the real economy.

Look at broader liquidity metrics. Don't stop at M2. Institutional cash pools, reverse repo facilities, and Eurodollar markets dictate global liquidity. Organizations like CrossBorder Capital and researchers at the Bank for International Settlements (BIS) track global liquidity indexes that capture credit creation far better than narrow 1970s definitions of cash.

How You Can Use This Right Now

You don't run the Federal Reserve, so debating academic monetary theory only matters if it helps you protect your money and make smarter business decisions. Fortunately, tracking monetary aggregates gives you a massive edge over people who only listen to financial news anchors reacting to yesterday's CPI print.

1. Bookmark the FRED M2SL chart. Go to the St. Louis Fed's website and pull up the "M2SL" data series. Switch the units to "Percent Change from Year Ago." Check it once a month when the Fed releases the H.6 money stock report. It takes thirty seconds. If you see year-over-year growth surging past 8% or 9%, start positioning your portfolio for inflation—think real estate, equities with pricing power, commodities, and short-duration bonds rather than long-term fixed-rate debt.

2. Watch the lag times. Monetary policy works with what Friedman called "long and variable lags"—typically 12 to 24 months. When M2 spikes or plunges, the economy doesn't react the next Tuesday. If you see broad money contracting sharply, don't wait for unemployment to spike before tightening up your business's cash reserves or refinancing variable-rate debt. You have a roughly one-year warning window before the slowdown hits corporate earnings.

3. Ignore "cost-push" inflation narratives. Every time inflation rises, politicians and pundits blame greedy corporations, unions, oil cartels, or shipping bottlenecks. Tune it out. Relative price shocks come and go, but sustained, broad-based inflation cannot survive without monetary fuel. Check the money supply growth rate; it will tell you whether price hikes are a temporary blip or a multi-year trend.

Monetarism never really died—central bankers just stopped looking at the dashboard while driving down the highway. Bringing money supply analysis back into the mainstream won't solve every economic problem, and it won't replace interest rate policy. It simply puts the fuel gauge back on the dashboard before the engine catches fire again.

MR

Mia Rivera

Mia Rivera is passionate about using journalism as a tool for positive change, focusing on stories that matter to communities and society.